Skip to content
Hefestos CapitalHefestosCapital

Insights

Closing a Company or Selling It: Which Pays More

The decision to close a company is rarely taken for financial reasons. The owner is tired, there is nobody to take over, the business has shrunk or the industry has moved. Liquidation looks like a tidy ending, and owners often start it without once checking whether anyone would buy the company. That check takes two or three weeks and costs nothing, while the difference in outcome is frequently several times over.

What liquidation produces

In a liquidation assets are sold off individually, receivables collected or written off, liabilities settled, and whatever remains belongs to the owner. Equipment fetches second-hand prices rather than book value. Stock goes at a discount because it is sold against a deadline. The procedure has its own costs and runs for months.

What matters most is what liquidation pays nothing at all for. The customer base, the contracts, the name, trained people, standing with suppliers, permits. Everything that makes the company earn disappears without a cent, because what is sold is things rather than a business.

What a sale produces

A buyer pays not for the assets but for the earnings those assets produce together with everything else. That is why even a small company with modest assets, if it has steady customers and sound profits, is worth a multiple of the sum of its things.

Take a company with EUR 200,000 of annual earnings before interest, tax and depreciation. Equipment is EUR 150,000 in the books, stock EUR 100,000, receivables EUR 200,000 and trade payables EUR 180,000. In liquidation the equipment realistically sells for about EUR 60,000, the stock for EUR 50,000, perhaps EUR 170,000 of receivables is collected, EUR 180,000 of payables is settled and about EUR 15,000 goes on the procedure. The owner is left with close to EUR 85,000.

The same company sold at a multiple of four on the same earnings gives an enterprise value of EUR 800,000. Even after adjusting for net debt and working capital, the owner leaves with an amount measured in hundreds of thousands rather than tens. The difference is not negotiating skill but what is being sold in the first place.

When a sale genuinely is not possible

There are cases where liquidation is the right answer and there is no point losing time. A company where all the work hangs on the owner personally, and leaves with them, has nothing to transfer. The same applies where a permit or licence is tied to a person, where the market has gone, or where the business has lost money for years with no visible way to change that. In those situations the only question is how to close with the least cost in the shortest time.

If the account is frozen

Here the routes separate. Voluntary liquidation assumes the company can settle all its obligations. A company that cannot does not close through liquidation but through a different procedure, and attempting a shortcut creates liability for those who decided it. That question goes to counsel before any filing. It is also worth knowing that a frozen company which still has customers and equipment sometimes achieves a better outcome by selling the business as a unit than through any form of closure.

What can be sold when the whole company cannot

Between selling the company and liquidating it lies ground owners often miss. A customer base with contracts has value to a competitor in the same field. Equipment that works as a unit is worth more than the individual machines. A lease on a good location transfers. A team that works well together is sometimes the reason someone buys, even when they buy nothing else. Each of those sales produces more than a liquidation sell-off.

The order that saves money

Establish first whether the company has a buyer and at what price, then decide. The reverse order does not exist, because liquidation cannot be undone and the business dies while you think about it: people leave, customers find alternatives, and what had value disappears within a few months. If it turns out there is no buyer, nothing is lost but a few weeks, and the decision to close is made with a clear conscience.

Where to go next

This compares commercial outcomes and is not legal or tax advice; the liquidation procedure, its conditions and tax consequences are checked with counsel and your accountant. If you are thinking about closing, the cheapest thing you can do first is find out what the company is worth to somebody else.